Wednesday, 12 June 2013

Papa don't preach!

When I was in primary school, two of my schoolmates who were initially bosom buddies just decided to stop talking to each other. I later found out that their fathers who had gone into business together fell into disrepute which led to massive showdown between the fathers. The animosity spilt over to the family members, hence the cold treatment towards each other. 40 years later, both guys having excelled in their respective fields of choice and their fathers had passed on, they just cannot bring themselves together to rekindle their childhood friendship.
There are some families who would continue their family feud for generation like the Pandavas and Gauravas which generated the Gita to teach man how to live in peace with each other and in equilibrium with nature. Sometimes, they just fight because all these while they have been fighting. The real reason is lost in time. 
It is interesting to note that at the grass root level, many do irrational things. People of different political ideologies clash with each other just so that their leaders can lead a cushy life, cheating them blind and remotely showing that they care for the well being of the same society that they are supposedly fighting for. People from different religious beliefs have no qualms in killing and torturing their fellow brothers and sisters to uphold the teaching and honour a religion (any religion) that promotes peace and tranquility.
Enen EPL football clubs have supporters who would be up in arms to defend the glory of their club while the owners laugh all the way to the bank as the injured supporters rush all the way to the hospital wincing in agony after a nice battering from the riot police!
Movies are supposed to entertain and feed the mind and soul. In Tamil Nadu, however, clashes between loyal members of famous Kollywood movie star fan club is not uncommon. For all you know, the stars are all buddies trying to make a living, whilst the supporters lose many man-hours trying to prove a point which was meant for entertainment anyway. 
Even there is so much of hatred and angers between the pawns at the grass root level, we do not see their leaders mauling or clobbering each other with tooth and nail!

Sunday, 9 June 2013

Banality of evil

As usual after our usual hard run on Sunday, during the breakfast of thosai, we got involved in our usual banter about events around the country.
This time around the subject was rather morbid, in particular about the death of an detainee by assault and the killing and unceremonial cremation of a millionairess recently. What makes a man do all these violent things to a fellow human being without flinching. Being a doctor, one of the group members could not stomach the idea of landing punches after punches and the coup de grace that tips the living daylights of the victim whilst looking straight into his eyes.
Unfortunately, I do not think that people of the medical profession are immune of this charge. Scores of heinous crimes against patients and even loved ones are testimony of this charge.
In fact, philosophers and psychologists have pondered upon this topic since the end of WW2. Hannah Arendt introduced the concept of banality of evil where people just did evil things that they were assigned to do without questioning and thinking of its consequence as if it was just banal (trivial) thing to do.
The abandoned 1971 Stanford prison experiment by Prof Philip Zimbaldo suggested that probably we all try to perform our roles too well. The prison guards, probably because of the absolute power given to them, act beyond the scope of their job with the aid of testesterone and ego. The prisoners go into submission because of their disadvantaged state and the stress hormones.
There must be some truth in Sigmund Freud's theory that man's needs are governed by their primodial primitive animalistic desires of food, violence and sexual gratification. Modernization and culture managed to rein these unsavoury traits which are not appropriate for living in a structured society. However, when the atmosphere is conducive or desperate, when they are amongst people of similar wavelength, these unabated evil behaviour may just be unleashed to its full glory.

Saturday, 8 June 2013

Another classic!

Safety Last (1923)
Malaysians who came of age in the 70s and 80s would have viewed Harold Lloyd's 'World of Comedy' over the terrestrial TV for umpteen times.
It is a 1923 silent full-length comedy with plenty of stunts which would give plenty of butterflies in the belly of those with a weak spot for heights. Despite losing a thumb and a forefinger in a previous stunt, Lloyd still managed to perform many of the stunts here.
The highlight of his comedy is the trick the camera plays on the viewers with the clever use of props. Like in the opening scene, the bars, priest, the noose and the emotional relatives makes it appear like a scene where Harold going to be hung when it is actually a scene at a ticketing counter at a railway station!
Harold leaves to work in town to save some marry his sweetheart.
Even though he is working as a lowly sales assistant in a textile store, he paints a rosy picture to his girlfriend by sending her pricey gifts.
The girlfriend, Mildred, decides to pay him a surprise visit, creating a comedy of errors in his work-place as he tries to con her that he is the General Manager!
After overhearing his bosses' offer of $1000 to anyone who could draw more customers to the store, Harold takes the challenge thinking that his pal who has the neck of scaling buildings would perform a death-defying stunts. On the said day of the stunt, his pal is chased by a cop and Harold Lloyd has to scale the building all by himself with hilarious and nail-biting moments.
As predicted, Harold succeeds and wins the heart of his girl!

Thursday, 6 June 2013

Practising medicine in medical practice?

Side Effects (2013)
A new thriller involving the medical profession and how the medical professionals, pharmaceutical companies and the patients themselves upset a system of healing which is portrayed as a wishy-washy pseudo-science where treatment seem to be dictated by the drug companies' promises and patients' choice rather then the medical professionals taking the lead. Everybody wants a good life, hence to need to cut corners and dump ethics and professionalism. Of course with Hollywood, you must have extramarital liaisons and even same sex affairs! And they say Bollywood is masala....
Emily is ecstatic to usher in her husband who is just released from jail after 4 years for insider trading. She seem to be listless, not enjoying intimate time with her guy. One day, she hit her car purposely on a concrete wall and is hospitalized for  concussion. Dr Banks (Jude Law) is the assigned psychiatrist to treat her.
Her past medical history revealed that she had been treated by a Dr Seibert (Catherine Zeta-Jones) as a teenager for depression.
After a series of failed treatment and side effects with a plethora of anti depressives, Emily is prescribed Ablixa which is shown to have tremendous positive effects on her daily life. A minor side effect, somnambulism (sleep walking) is passed off by Dr Banks as a harmless side effect.
One day, Emily stabs her husband to death in one of this sleep walking episodes. This episode opens a can of worms - Banks is shown to be an overworking overloaded doctor, unethical doctor who allegedly had an unsavoury conduct with one of his female patients. His partners decide to terminate his partnership and his wife walks out on him with his stepson. Dr Seibert, who had suggested to Dr Banks about using Albixa actually had discovered the side effect of sleep walking.
Emily is found not guilty on reason of insanity. Dr Banks loses more than just his reputation and has to go on spree to discover the truth.
To cut through all the mumbo jumbo, Dr Banks discover a complex plot between Dr Seibert and her lesbian girlfriend, Emily, to use the side effect to kill off her husband who had deprived her of a luxurious life.
In the end, Dr Banks is reunited with his wife and her son from a previous marriage.
A disturbing observation that is also seen here is how pharmaceutical companies have clout on doctors' decision to prescribe a particular drug. As a grateful Pavlov's dog, the doctors, many of whom are nicely padded with the companies freebies, free lunches, sponsored conferences in places remotely linked to medicine like Las Vegas, feel compelled to oblige for services rendered! The business minded world has pushed advertisement of drugs to the limit that patients themselves feel that a particular other medicine would be better in their condition, just because so-and-so is using it and feels better. It looks like the doctor is just a lame duck sitting there just to receive the brickbats in case something goes wrong.
fictitious drug!
Gone are days where the paternalistic role of doctors is treasured and given utmost credence. Now, he is just another employer in the 'system' with vested interest!
If being pelleted from all sides is not enough, in Dr Banks' case, it appears like he also has to do things to please his wife and stepson. Even though he is the only breadwinner of the family at the time of crisis, the dynamics of his family dictates that he is longer the head of the family. Even in crisis, his wife is not standing by him but rather she walks out on him. The husband in present day modern family is just a castrated tiger who has not only been domesticated but has lost his majestic roar and respect. He seem to living a life just to keep his subjects (family members) contented and provided for....Kabish? capisce? Comprende? 

Tuesday, 4 June 2013

You really think we learn from history?

The Living Dead (1995)
Written and Produced by Adam Curtis

#1. On the Desperate Edge of Now.
This episode takes through the victors attempt of suppressing history. The victorious Allied Forces successfully rewrote the history of the Germans. The Germans were portrayed as the pinnacle of all evil through the doctored Nazi propaganda films, conveniently blanking out their sufferings and deeds. Hermann Goering's testimony at the Nuremberg trial was sped through without listening to the justification of Nazi party's path of life. Goering's justification of why Germany took the path of Fascism over democracy to steamroll the country into modernity after WW1 when democracy had failed was just pushed aside. Instead, testimony from low ranking Nazi officers were given credence.
In a single trial, the Allied Forces justified to the world their march into an evil war to ward off an evil regime. The suffering Germans were too traumatized to fight the altered course of history but instead suppressed that time of their history. The US used that sanitized history to control the course of West Germany in effort to combat the growing prowess of the Communist Soviet in the Cold War era.
Even though the final account of the Second World War paints the Allied Forces as liberators of Europe, American veterans had recurrent nightmares of the brutality of their Army to young Germans and civilians.
They thought that part of German was long forgotten but it kept resurfacing like a blob of fetid air from the swamp. In 1968, their old wound was rekindled by the 1968 students' rebellion and Red Army uprising.
Just when the Europeans thought that they had left their savage past behind, the brutal events occurring around the Bosnian War in the 90s was evidence that their inner evil is very much still alive!

#2. You Have Used Me as a Fish Long Enough
It all started in 1938 when Dr Wilfred Penfield in Montreal, operating the brain for seizures, discovered various areas of the brain where information and memory could be stored. This discovery excited many psychologists, including Dr Ewen Cameron. After witnessing the terrible acts committed by man in WW2 during the proceedings of the Nuremberg trial, scientists were toying the idea of suppressing unpleasant memories. It further progressed to device ways to make a clean slate of the mind and implanting thoughts. With the Cold War looming, this process was used for 'brain washing' to spy into each other's territory with the American thinking that the Soviets were superior to them in mind manipulation. There were even theories which suggested that Lee Oswald was brainwashed by the Russians to assassinate JFK.
At the end of the day, all the presumed good work failed to suppress unpleasant thoughts. It only wrecked some lives. The dangerous  memories of man kept trapped deep in the crevices of the human mind.
Since mind manipulation was unsuccessful, scientists tried to develop artificial intelligence to do human's dirty work, especially in wars. A living example of this is the wide use of guided missile and intelligent bombs in the Iraq War.

#3. The Attic
This episode shows how Margaret Thatcher used the nostalgia of the glorious past of the British to boost the public morale to bring the country to greater heights. This similar technique was also used by Winston Churchill during the WW2 when he stood alone against the Nazi's advances.
Coldwitz Castle, a tight security prison in Germany was where Airey Neave proved to be a British hero in 1941. He managed to escape incarceration through a trap door that even the Germans did not know about. He later became an English MP.
In the 70s, Britain became chaotic with industrial strikes and the values held by Brits during the war slipping away. Its power was also slipping away.
10, Downing Street.
The same Neave was the play-maker, after being discontented with Labour Party policies, who introduced Thatcher as a possible PM candidate.
After winning the elections in 1975, Thatcher tried to instill patriotism and romanticism of their glorious past to boost economy. Even though this helped to boost the morale of the soldier during the Falklands War and gave them pride, the ghost of the past did come haunting them. The Irish, with their own side of history from their perspective were up in arms against them. Neave was killed in an IRA initiated car bomb.
In order to boost economy, the market was freed with minimal central interference. This was also their own undoing when panic selling crash the market on Black Monday in 1987 after a freak hurricane attack. She received the same fate as Churchill did. After being a key player in the course of WW2, reality hit Britain when the war was over. Reality hit them. The post war realized that they were literally bankrupt with only a past to boast about. Churchill lost the elections and was not even considered in the post war reconstruction of Europe.
(# In keeping with her obsession of remembering of the glorious past, Thatcher refurbished 10, Downing Street in the 18th century styled setting and she lived in the attic!)

Either way, the human species seem to be at the losing end. Forgetting old unpleasant history is sometimes necessary but not possible. It would still come and haunt you later in life. On the other end, we cannot go on living by basking in our laurels for long. Some old evil things in our past would catch up with us.
We have to look forward to move on....

On Nattukottai Chettiars...